Musical Intruments Review
  • Home
  • Harmonica Reviews
    Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica Review

    Hering Membi Chromatic and Vintage Harp 1923

    Fender/Lee Oskar Limited Edition Harmonica

    Fender/Lee Oskar Limited Edition Harmonica

    Hohner 270 Deluxe Review

    Hohner 270 Deluxe

  • Intruments
    • All
    • Drums
    • Guitar
    • Piano
    • Recording
    • Saxophone
    • Trumpet
    • Ukulele
    18 Best Phin Guitar Reviews 2020

    18 Best Phin Guitar Reviews 2020

    9 Best Lap Harp Reviews 2020

    9 Best Lap Harp Reviews 2020

    20 Best Pocket Guitar Reviews 2020

    20 Best Pocket Guitar Reviews 2020

    4 Best Rainstick Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Rainstick)

    4 Best Rainstick Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Rainstick)

    20 Best Music Theory Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Music Theory)

    20 Best Music Theory Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Music Theory)

    20 Best Ocarina Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Ocarina)

    20 Best Ocarina Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Ocarina)

    20 Best Mozart Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Mozart)

    20 Best Mozart Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Mozart)

    20 Best Marimba Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Marimba)

    20 Best Marimba Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books to Learn Marimba)

    20 Best Lute Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books To Learn Lute)

    20 Best Lute Book Reviews 2020 (Best Books To Learn Lute)

    Old-Time Music

    Top 10 Best Humbucker Pickups For All Budgets 2020 Review

  • Other
    Best Tin Whistle In 2020 – Top 10 Rated Review

    Best Tin Whistle In 2020 – Top 10 Rated Review

    Top 8 Best Blues Harmonica In 2020 Reviews & Buyers Guide

    Top 8 Best Blues Harmonica In 2020 Reviews & Buyers Guide

    Best Hardware Sequencers In 2020 – Top Picks Reviews

    Best Hardware Sequencers In 2020 – Top Picks Reviews

    Pioneer PLX-500-K Review [2020] – Old-Time Music

    Pioneer PLX-500-K Review [2020] – Old-Time Music

    Teenage Engineering OP-1 Portable Synthesizer Review

    Teenage Engineering OP-1 Portable Synthesizer Review

    Best DJ Mixers For All Budget 2020 – Ultimate Reviews

    Best DJ Mixers For All Budget 2020 – Ultimate Reviews

    RME ADI-2 DAC Review – Don’t buy before read this!

    RME ADI-2 DAC Review – Don’t buy before read this!

    Top 5 Best Mountain Dulcimers On The Market Reviews

    Top 5 Best Mountain Dulcimers On The Market Reviews

    Top 10 Best Mandolins On The Market 2020 Reviews

    Top 10 Best Mandolins On The Market 2020 Reviews

No Result
View All Result
Musical Intruments Review
No Result
View All Result
Musical Intruments Review
Home Harmonica Reviews

Hering Membi Chromatic and Vintage Harp 1923

vina by vina
June 23, 2020
in Harmonica Reviews
0
Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica Review
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica Review

Hering Membi Chromatic

Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica Review

If I recall correctly, Hering have used the name Membi for at least a couple of other harmonicas over the years. This particular one is a 12-hole solo tuned chromatic with chromed brass covers and a synthetic comb. Rather then being injection molded, the comb is milled from a solid piece of black plastic. The 0.9mm thick reedplates are nickel (I think) plated and are attached by three larger screws a the rear and two smaller ones along the front edge of the reedplates. There are a pair of soccer goalpost shaped brass supports to help reduce the chance of crushing the covers if you accidentally sit down with the harmonica in your back pocket.

The slide assembly is a fairly typical three piece assembly with a single slide bumper at the spring end and works very smoothly and quietly. The slide button has a flat face with a nicely textured surface to reduce finger slippage and the square holed brass mouthpiece is chrome plated and very comfortable in the mouth. The mouthpiece and slide assembly is attached with screws that go directly into the comb material, so if you remove it for cleaning, make sure that you get the screws correctly seated in their thread when you reassemble it (the same goes for chromatics with wood combs, of course).

The valves are the typical Hering two piece flaps which work quietly on the sample I have for review, even when I played it cold. The reed are of a medium length, reed adjustment is very consistent with average to low gaps and tuning is extremely good at A=445Hz. Nothing particularly innovative about it, but overall a very good quality chromatic. Available in the key of C only, it comes in a nice semi-rigid zippered case with plenty of space to hold a few extra items, along with a microfibre polishing cloth and a rather neat drawstring pouch.

Hering Vintage Harp 1923

Hering Vintage Harp 1923

The Hering Vintage Harp is not new, but as I’ve never reviewed it here and I was sent a sample from a recent production run, I thought I’d post a brief review. The Vintage Harp is a very traditional Richter diatonic, with a sandwich style construction and has a noticeable heft to it. The covers are vented at the ends like the Hohner Marine Band and are made of brass with some sort of lacquer finish that feels very smooth and slides reasonably well in the mouth, as well as looking quite distinctive. The reedplates are significantly thicker than usual at 1.2mm (approx. .05″) and attached to the comb with five Phillips head screws.

The comb is made of wood and has been heavily lacquered on all the exposed surfaces, but not on the parts that come into contact with the reedplates. The sample I have is in the key of C and uses Hering’s medium slot reeds. Tolerances between the reeds and the slot look good and reed adjustment is very consistent with a medium gap. The tuning is excellent – 7 limit Just Intonation with the blow reeds rooted around A=442 and the draw reeds tuned slightly sharper.

Overall, this sample plays very well with nicely consistent response over the whole range of the harp. The thicker reedplates seem to add some punch to the tone and the tuning gives some very pure sounding chords, although with the “flat” sounding 5 draw and 9 draw that can sound out of place in certain playing styles, so this is definitely a harp for the more traditional player. Equally definitely, it is not a harp for the overblower, at least not without lots of work on the reeds to damp the tendency towards squealing.

It used to come in a rather cheap looking hard plastic box, but I am pleased to report that it now comes in a rather nice zip-up semi-hardshell form-fitting case. (I hear that Hering have recently upgraded the cases for most of their harmonicas.) The Vintage Harp is available in all 12 standard keys, as well as a 12-key set and a 6-key set (G, A, C, D, E and F).

Feedback over the six years or so that the Vintage Harp has been available seems to have been generally quite positive. I don’t recall any complaints about the comb swelling, although I have heard a few people state that the exposed edges of the reedplates have an odd taste to them. I think this probably depends on individual mouth chemistry. Reports of reed longevity have been mixed, with some people claiming to have blown them out in a matter of weeks, others saying that their have lasted for years.

Obviously, your mileage will undoubtedly vary, but I will note that on my sample the tuning had left some diagonal file marks across the reeds that are unlikely to help reed longevity. That criticism aside, if you are looking for a good traditional blues harp, the 1923 is well worth checking out.

Update

Hering have been under new management since July 2017. However, at the time of writing (June 2018), they do not seem to be back in production yet and there is currently no information available on when harmonicas will be made again and which models will be available. It may be worth keeping an eye on their Facebook page for updates.

The Review

Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica

67% Score

The Hering 1923 Vintage Harp looks like something straight out of a museum. Yet, it's an inexpensive mouth harp that anyone can afford. That's a good thing, since most experts seem to agree we all know a novice would need to play it. While the Hering 1923 is considered to be one of Rod Piazza's favorites, it isn't without its share of problems, especially when it for you to the reeds. Nevertheless, the harmonica as a whole has a solid construction and a good extra fat. It also has a good tone for the money, but some declare that the tone is not quite as good as Hohner harmonicas that are in the same price range.

PROS

  • Inexpensive
  • Easy to play

CONS

  • Prone to reed problems
  • Sound quality not as good as models with similar prices

Review Breakdown

  • Value 0%
  • Quality 0%
  • Sound 0%
Previous Post

Fender/Lee Oskar Limited Edition Harmonica

Next Post

Fender Redondo Player Review – Good for your choice?

vina

vina

Next Post
Fender Redondo Player Review - Good for your choice?

Fender Redondo Player Review - Good for your choice?

Old-Time Music

Ibanez Talman Series TCM50NT Review

Old-Time Music

Epiphone AJ-220S Solid Top Acoustic Guitar Review

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Average Score

67%
  • Value 0%
  • Quality 0%
  • Sound 0%
The Hering 1923 Vintage Harp looks like something straight out of a museum. Yet, it's an inexpensive mouth harp that anyone can afford. That's a good thing, since most experts seem to agree we all know a novice would need to play it. While the Hering 1923 is considered to be one of Rod Piazza's favorites, it isn't without its share of problems, especially when it for you to the reeds. Nevertheless, the harmonica as a whole has a solid construction and a good extra fat. It also has a good tone for the money, but some declare that the tone is not quite as good as Hohner harmonicas that are in the same price range.

PROS

  • Inexpensive
  • Easy to play

CONS

  • Prone to reed problems
  • Sound quality not as good as models with similar prices
Advertisement Banner

Recommended Reading

    TOP REVIEW

    Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica Review

    Hering Vintage Harp Harmonica

    The Hering 1923 Vintage Harp looks like something straight out of
    Fender/Lee Oskar Limited Edition Harmonica

    Lee Oskar Harmonica

    If you are looking for an instrument that you can rely $43.99
    Hohner 270 Deluxe Review

    Hohner 270 Deluxe

    The Hohner 270 Super Chromonica was released more than 70 years $241.89

    About Us

    We bring you the best Premium WordPress Themes that perfect for news, magazine, personal blog, etc. Check our landing page for details.

    Follow Us

    Popular Tag

    Acoustic Guitar chromatic harmonica diatonic harmonica Hohner

    Recent News

    18 Best Phin Guitar Reviews 2020

    18 Best Phin Guitar Reviews 2020

    August 30, 2020
    9 Best Lap Harp Reviews 2020

    9 Best Lap Harp Reviews 2020

    August 28, 2020
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Privacy & Policy
    • Contact

    © 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Harmonica Reviews
    • Intruments
    • Other

    © 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.